Excerpt from the introduction
The cognitive anthropology of science is at the crossroads
of several rapidly developing disciplines: cognitive science, which increasingly
provides tools for the study of scientific thinking; science studies,
and in particular the anthropology of science, which is enriching the
subject with numerous case studies; naturalised epistemology, which is
constantly reworking its philosophical assumptions thus opening new directions
for the naturalist study of science; and finally, cognitive anthropology
and ethnoscience, which make a valuable contribution in terms of theory,
methods and empirical data.
Thus, the cognitive anthropology of science benefits from several paradigms,
traditions and research methods. First, cognitive anthropologists can
show how cognitive constraints have contributed, together with historical
and cultural factors, to the contents of a given science. Second, sciences
are cultural objects of particular relevance for the cross-cultural study
of notions such as truth or causality, and cognitive operations such as
reasoning or categorising. Third, sciences can be analysed as specific
cultural models or schemas that frame individuals' cognition. Scientists
at work, and, more controversially, people in their everyday activities,
appeal to specific ways of thinking informed by the 'culture of science'.
Fourth, scientific practice can be analysed as cognition distributed among
scientists and scientific instruments.
And yet, the project remains controversial. This is so because of its
explicit objective to combine and integrate the explanatory power of the
cognitive and social sciences.
CONTENTS:
Christophe Heintz
Introduction: Why there should be a cognitive anthropology of science
Roy Ellen
From ethno-science to science, or `What the indigenous knowledge debate
tells us about how scientists define their project'
Marta Spranzi
Galileo and the mountains of the moon: analogical reasoning, models and
metaphors in scientific discovery
Deveraux Poling & Margaret Evans
Religious Belief, Scientific Expertise, and Folk Ecology
Jean Paul Van Bendegem & Bart Van Kerkhove
The Unreasonable
richness of mathematics
David Gooding
Cognition, Construction and Culture: Visual theories in the sciences
Wolff-Michael Roth
Emergence
of Graphing Practices in Scientific Research
Morana Alac & Ed Hutchins
I see what you are
saying: Action as cognition in fMRI brain mapping practice
Elke Kurz-Milke, Nancy Nersessian & Wendy Newstetter
What
has history to do with cognition? Interactive methods for studying research
laboratories
Angeles Erana & Sergio Martinez,
The heuristic structure of scientific knowledge
Ryan Tweney
Replication and the Experimental Ethnography of Science
Ronald Giere
The Problem of
Agency in Scientific Distributed Cognitive Systems
|